No More Federal Funds for CCS, Guilbeault Says, as Fossils Report Record Profits

Canada’s big oil companies are making record profits this year and should be investing some of that extra cash to curb their greenhouse gas emissions, Environment Minister Steven Guilbeault said Thursday.

His remarks came a week after Cenovus CEO Alex Pourbaix told analysts during a company conference call that a new federal tax credit isn’t good enough to convince the major oilsands producers to start building a proposed carbon capture and storage project, The Canadian Press reports.

Carbon capture and storage traps fossil companies’ production emissions at their source and funnels them back underground or into products that can permanently store them, such as cement. The technology is controversial, with many climate scientists arguing it is unproven, expensive, and allows fossil fuel production to continue.

The new refundable investment tax credit introduced in the recent federal budget is worth 50 to 60% of the investment for carbon capture, and 37.5% for transportation, storage or use of the emissions. Projects that go to enhanced oil recovery—the technology that uses captured emissions to squeeze more oil out of the ground, and had been the use for 81% of the world’s captured carbon as of January, 2021—won’t qualify.

The tax credit will provide an estimated C$2.6 billion over the next five years, and $1.5 billion annually after that until 2030. Last year the Canadian Association of Petroleum Producers asked Ottawa to design the tax credit so it pays for 75% of the cost of carbon capture projects.

Pourbaix said the industry will need more than what was offered to move on the investments. But Guilbeault said in an interview Thursday that isn’t going to happen.

“We won’t be putting even more and more money on the table,” he said. “They have to invest as well.”

He said Pourbaix’s comments are disappointing and that it’s time for industry to come to the table to show what it plans to invest to protect its future in a world where demand for oil and gas diminishes—and demand for unabated oil and gas diminishes faster.

“We want to invest in your sector to ensure that the sector and workers still have jobs, 10, 15 years from now, when more and more, the world will be moving toward a low-carbon future,” Guilbeault said. “So we’re putting our money where our mouth is, and we think that they should do the same.”

And he said they have the money to do it. The same day Pourbaix talked about the tax credit, Cenovus reported its best first-quarter profit ever, of $1.6 billion. A year ago, profits were $220 million.

Cenovus has not yet responded to a request for comment.

The company is not alone, with the price of oil being driven up by the war in Ukraine, pandemic-related supply chain issues, and surging demand as pandemic lockdowns ease. Imperial Oil reported first quarter profits of $1.17 billion, its best first quarter in 30 years. On Thursday, Canadian Natural Resources Ltd. reported profits of $3.1 billion, compared with $1.38 billion a year ago.

“These companies are making record profits, they should be investing some of them into ensuring that they have a future,” Guilbeault said.

Last week, Pourbaix said oil prices rise and fall so decisions about investing in carbon capture can’t be based on current prices. “Oil prices right now are obviously very attractive, but we know probably before that project is ever in service, we’ll probably test the bottom end of those prices again,” he said.

The oil and gas sector produced more than one-quarter of Canada’s total emissions in 2020. Ottawa is currently estimating the sector must cut its emissions almost 40% from 2020 levels by 2030 if Canada is to meet its current emissions target.

A Royal Bank of Canada analysis released last week said cutting oilsands emissions 40% by 2030 will cost between $45 and $65 billion.

Guilbeault said the industry has invested to cut its emissions. Although production increases mean overall emissions have risen, emissions per barrel are down 11% between 2005 and 2020 industry-wide, and in the oilsands alone they’re down 12%.

“So they have invested in efficiency over the last few years and more than a few,” he said. “I think the question now is, is it enough? And the answer to that is clearly no.”

Earlier this year, more than 400 climate scientists wrote to Finance Minister Chrystia Freeland urging her not to proceed with the tax credit because the technology is unproven, expensive, and a massive subsidy to the oil and gas industry.

At a committee hearing in Ottawa earlier this week, NDP MP Laurel Collins demanded Guilbeault hear that plea.

“This is absolutely the wrong direction,” she said. “Why are you not listening to them?”

This report by The Canadian Press was first published May 5, 2022.